Harbor & ValeRealty
The Old Harbor Rectory, exterior illustration
Old Harbor · Port Ellery, CA

The Old Harbor Rectory

A 1904 stone rectory in the historic district, restored room by room

$4,100,000
0103
Scroll
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
3 Full · 1 Partial
Interior
3,860 sq ft
Year Built
1904
Style
Stone Revival
The Old Harbor Rectory, exterior illustration
The Old Harbor Rectory, interior illustration
The Old Harbor Rectory, site plan illustration
The Residence

The Old Harbor Rectory

Two-foot walls, twelve-foot ceilings, a garden behind a wall.

A 1904 stone rectory in the historic district, restored room by room

The rectory of the old harbor chapel, built of local sandstone in 1904 and restored over six years with the original millwork, plaster and fireplaces intact. Behind a high stone wall, a garden of lavender and fig leads to a carriage house with a studio above.
Highlights
  • Historic District
  • Walled Garden
  • Original Millwork
  • Carriage House
  • Wine Cellar
  • Walk to Harbor
Property Details

The particulars

Style
Stone Revival
Stories
2
Lot Size
0.36 acres
Registry #
HV-2608
Year Built
1904
Listing Agent
Tobias Renfrew
Property Type
single family
Registry Status
Quiet Listing
Roof
Slate
Water
Municipal
Cooling
Heat Pump
Heating
Radiant, Heat Pump
Exterior Construction
Stone, Plaster
Kitchen
Chef's Kitchen with Butler's Pantry
Flooring
White Oak, Limestone
Fireplace Total
2
Interior Features
Historic District, Walled Garden, Original Millwork
Pool
None
View
Garden
Parking
2 Spaces, Garage
__bikeScore
64
__walkScore
78
__priceHistory
[{"date":"2026-06-24","event":"Recorded in Registry","priceUsd":4100000,"source":"Harbor & Vale Realty"}]
The Old Harbor Rectory, interior illustration

Old Harbor

Neighborhood

Living in Old Harbor

Old Harbor is one of the enclaves that make up Port Ellery, a small harbor town on the Central Coast. Residences here trade quietly and rarely.

Harbor

Minutes to the marina, the breakwater and the working fish market.

Village

The Old Harbor district's cafes, bookshop and Saturday market.

Country

Trail access to the ridge and the vale within a short drive.

Aerial View

From above

Generating aerial view…
Location

Where it lives

Loading map…
Estimated Monthly Cost

Mortgage Calculator

Estimated Monthly Total
$25,306
per month
Principal & Interest
$21,547
Property Taxes
$3,758
HOA / Maintenance
$0
Loan Amount
$3,280,000

Estimates are illustrative only and exclude homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance, and closing costs. Verify with a licensed lender before relying on these figures.

True Cost of Ownership

What it really costs

Estimated Total Per Month
$30,752

$21,822 mortgage + $3,758 taxes + $1,435 insurance + $3,417 maintenance reserve

Mortgage
$21,822

20% down · 30yr · 7.00%

Fixed Monthly
$5,193

Taxes · Insurance

Variable
$3,737

Utilities · Maintenance reserve

Estimates assume 20% down, 30-year fixed at 7%. Verify with a licensed lender.

Market Pulse

How this compares

Days on Market
30
days listed
15 days vs avg
Price / Sqft
$1,062
ZIP 93499 median ~ $235
351.9% vs avg
30-Yr Fixed Rate
-
FRED · data pending
National avg

Baselines are national and ZIP-level approximations · Data refreshes hourly

Commute

How far from anywhere

Car
-
Transit
-
Bike
-
Walk
-
Climate & Lifestyle

Living conditions

Flood Risk
Earthquake
Radon
Wildfire
Air Quality
Pollen
Connectivity

Internet & Fiber Availability

Source: FCC National Broadband Map

The Setting

Walk & Transit

78
Walk Score

Very walkable - most errands can be accomplished on foot.

64
Bike Score

Somewhat bikeable - some errands can be accomplished on foot.

Listing Activity

Price History

DateEventPriceSource
2026-06-24Recorded in Registry$4,100,000Harbor & Vale Realty
Represented By

The Old Harbor Rectory

Price
$4,100,000
Address
61 Chapel Street, Port Ellery, CA 93499
Registry #
HV-2608
Listing Broker
Tobias Renfrew · Harbor & Vale Realty

An independent, broker-owned California real estate firm. Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Buyers should verify all material facts independently.

Request A Private Showing

Tobias Renfrew shows this residence personally, by appointment.

We do not share or sell your information.

Listed
June 24, 2026
Days on Market
75
MLS Number
HV-2608
Status
Active
Last Updated
September 7, 2026